Homemade Butter

by Rebekahcooked up on December 18, 2011

Remember when you shook that baby food jar around in kindergarten and made butter in your class? Fun stuff, right? I have great news. It is still exactly that easy to make butter at home. Or easier, if you have a mixer.

It’s ready to eat in about 20 minutes, and if you’ve got some herbs, roasted garlic or peppercorns around, you can turn it into an elegant hostess gift.

I’d also like to announce that tomorrow through Friday shall henceforth be known as Holiday Treat Week. I hope you’ll stop by!

Here’s what you need:

  • Whipping cream. Doesn’t have to be “heavy” but it can be.
  • Coarse salt
  • Any fresh herbs you would like to add

With this batch I think I used a little over a cup of cream. So, here are the directions: 1. Put the cream in your mixer, or in a mixing bowl:

2. Turn mixer on medium. 3. Walk away. Or don’t walk away, if you are using a hand mixer. But don’t change what you do between now and the end.

First, the cream will become whipped. Then it will reach that stage where you can see that you’ve whipped it too much.

See how the texture is inconsistent? This cream is too-whipped.

Next, you will start to see some solids separate from the liquids:

But it’s not quite there yet. When it’s ready, there will be only a few large distinct chunks of fat, with a lot of milk-like liquid surrounding it:

Now you can turn off the mixer. Try not to lose any of the liquid as you take only the solids out of the bowl and remove them to a paper towel or a clean dish towel.

Use this towel to try what liquid is left in the butter. Then, give it a heavy sprinkle of coarse salt (if you want) and to press it into whatever shape you like. Top with roasted garlic, herbs – whatever you like.

And that stuff that’s left? Save it! That would be buttermilk. Go makes some pancakes.

More like this:


  1. BEST POST YET. So trying this soon!

    Comment by Lauren Madras — December 18, 2011 at 3:31 pm

  2. Thanks! 😀 We have gobbled almost all of ours up… I made potato rolls, the butter and a beef/barley stew for Dave’s arrival back home last night!

    Comment by bekky — December 18, 2011 at 3:32 pm

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Other side recipes to try:

Chorizo Jalapeño Poppers

An ode to one of my favorite cuisines - Tex Mex - with a little upgrade in the form of chorizo and more cheese.

Tomato Peach Panzanella with Prosciutto

In the summer, simple food is sometimes the best.

Healthy Lunch Idea: Grapefruit Walnut Salad

A salad so nice, we made it twice! No seriously. Two days in a row.